How YouTube Search Actually Picks Which Videos to Show

I filmed my first vlog on a borrowed phone in 2019 and spent about six hours editing eleven minutes of me walking around a market. It got 14 views. Nine of them were probably me.

Prefer to watch? Here’s a good video on this from YouTube Creators:

What I didn’t understand back then is that nobody was ever going to find that video. The title was “Saturday!!” and the description was empty. YouTube had no idea what it was about, so it showed it to nobody.

What YouTube actually looks at

YouTube’s own help page on how search works boils it down to three things: how relevant your video is to what someone typed, how people engage with it once they click, and whether your channel looks like a decent source on the topic. That’s it. Subscriber count isn’t on the list, which is honestly the best news a small channel can get.

In plain terms:

  • Say what the video is about in the title, using words people would actually search.
  • Say it again, normally, in the first line or two of the description.
  • Then actually deliver it early. If your title says “budget camera setup” and you spend the first minute on a sponsor and a story about your cat, people bounce and the video sinks.

The logged-in trap

This one fooled me for months. I’d search my own keyword, see my video sitting at #2, and feel great. Then a friend searched the same thing and couldn’t find it on the first screen at all. YouTube personalises results for you, and you watch your own stuff constantly, so of course it ranks you high.

Open a private/incognito window when you check. It’s humbling, but it’s the real number.

If you liked this post, be sure to subscribe for updates! Follow along via RSS or bookmark this post.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top